Aug 20 2008

Can fat make you thin?

Today Harvard Medical School researchers announced that brown fat can make you lose weight.

It seems that there are two different types of adipose tissue: white fat and brown fat. The white fat sits around because it is very lazy and stuffing itself on triglycerides. But brown fat! Oh my goodness! Brown fat has get up and go!

Quoting from the original article at Wired Science: Scientists Make a Fat-Burning Fat:

Brown fat is quite different. It’s full of mitochondria — the body’s energy-producing cellular machines — and burns calories to produce heat.

Abundant in babies, whom it helps keep warm, brown fat is found only in traces in adults. But with a flick of two genetic switches, scientists showed that cells destined to become muscle have the potential to become brown fat.

Emphasis mine.

Asked whether his technique could deprive the body of muscle, Spiegelman said that precursor muscle cells are self-replenishing: Redirect a few into brown fat, and they’ll be quickly replaced.

This is extremely preliminary research but they are showing that:

  • Adding gene PRDM16 to cells will turn those cells into brown fat and
  • Their reasoning is that the brown fat will burn “excess” fat.
  • They are years, perhaps decades, away from research that could turn this into a prescription pill. And of course it might not ever come to that. This is all very new and they are still very far from animal testing.

    I find all of this research fascinating and I love knowing more about how the human body works.

    But.

    Things that freak the crap out of me on this brown fat research.

  • One – Genetic engineering on human beings really freaks me out. I know it’s supposed to be great and sciencey and I usually love the sciencey stuff, really I love it — I have subscription to Scientific American so you know I’m telling the truth about loving the science but the thing that I love about Science is that it’s all about finding out how nature works. I love finding out how it’s all put together by taking it all apart and looking inside. But altering the destination of cells? Ewwwwwww.
  • Two – I am not a freak of nature. God did not make any mistakes with me. I am made right. I am a perfect being and this is my perfect body. Some of us have more white fat than others. Weight does not equal sick. Stop trying to fix me!
  • Three – Am I being duplicitous? I wonder if I would feel differently if they were altering the destination of cancer cells and turning them into farts. Wouldn’t I be happy about that? I think I would, except for the destruction of our ozone layer what with all the additional cancer farts in the atmosphere.
  • Edit: men-in-full makes this very important observation in her comment:

    Something else to think about – the brain IIRC is “white fat,” stuffed with cholesterol & triglycerides. What if some of that genetic manipulation “leaks” into the brain, and messes with brain fat?

    Sounds like a losing proposition to me.

    Links to the two Nature articles available online by the Harvard team: Nature: PRDM16 controls a brown fat/skeletal muscle switch, and Nature: New role of bone morphogenetic protein 7 in brown adipogenesis and energy expenditure. A synopsis of each article is available but to read the articles in full will require either a login (if you or your company subscribes) or a payment of $32.00.